A ruckus in session as the Punjab Assembly has approved the ‘controversial’ Defamation Bill 2024, despite vehement protests from the opposition and journalists say Punjab govt stabbed in our back after holding talks.
The bill, purportedly aimed at curbing the spread of fake news, faced strong opposition from media bodies, branding it “draconian” in its current form.
Disregarding pleas from media representatives to postpone the bill, Punjab’s Finance and Parliamentary Affairs Minister, Mujtaba Mian Shuja-ur-Rehman, introduced it in the House.
Earlier attempts by journalist representatives to persuade Punjab Information Minister Azma Bokhari to defer the bill were in vain.
As the bill was presented, chaos erupted in the House, with journalists boycotting proceedings and the opposition vehemently opposing its passage. Opposition Leader Ahmed Khan Bhachar labeled the bill a “black law,” declaring his side would not partake in its approval. Journalist leaders were of the view that the government stabbed them in the back after holding negotiation over the bill.
Despite opposition amendments being rejected, lawmakers from opposing benches protested loudly, even tearing copies of the bill.
The bill stipulates defamation as a civil offense, allowing individuals to pursue legal action without the burden of proving actual damage. It extends to addressing fake news disseminated through digital platforms like YouTube and social media, with tribunals mandated to resolve cases within six months.
The Human Rights Commission of Pakistan (HRCP) voiced grave concerns over the bill, criticizing its establishment of parallel judicial structures and expedited adjudication processes. The HRCP condemned the expedited timeframe for resolving cases and the preferential treatment afforded to holders of constitutional offices.
Lahore Press Club President Arshad Ansari condemned the bill as an affront to press freedom, vowing robust protests. He stressed the need for thorough consultation with stakeholders and warned of further action.
The Joint Action Committee (JAC) of media bodies echoed Ansari’s sentiments, advocating for a balanced approach that safeguards individual rights while upholding freedom of expression. They urged the Punjab and federal governments to engage in extensive discussions before proceeding with the legislation.
